Commodity Masters

  /  News   /  Need to Know: Here’s the factor that mattered most to driving stocks — and it sure wasn’t interest rates

Need to Know: Here’s the factor that mattered most to driving stocks — and it sure wasn’t interest rates

In a week when central bank actions have dominated the headlines, from the Federal Reserve’s decision to start tapering to the Bank of England blindsiding markets by standing pat, it’s worth taking a step back as to how much rates really matter.

Mitch Rubin, co-chief investment officer at RiverPark Capital and manager of both its long/short opportunity and large growth funds, chided the obsession with thinking about how isolated economic variables will impact markets. “Economists, pundits and market strategists always note that they are simply highlighting situations where — all else being equal — one action, such as higher rates, could have a significant negative impact on specific investments, such as higher multiple stocks and/or longer duration assets,” he said in the third-quarter investment letter. “Maybe so, but, we would observe that all else is literally NEVER equal.”

To prove his point, he looked back at the list of 21 largest companies by market cap in the S&P 500, Russell 1000 growth and Russell 1000 value indexes at the end of 2007. From there, he points out, these companies experienced a lot. “Over the next nearly 14 years through today, we had the Great Financial Crisis, both Democratic and Republican control over the White House and Congress, multiple geopolitical ‘crises’ and then the COVID pandemic,” he said.


But what really mattered in predicting returns is at what rate, and in what direction, did company earnings compound.

Two of the three best performing stocks were also the most expensive stocks back in 2007, he noted. “High PE + Strong Earnings can still result in best in class stock performance — even if the multiple contracts materially,” he said. Another interesting point was that JPMorgan Chase

did well despite the industry it operated in getting crushed. “Management and specific company characteristics still matter just as much, if not more, to stock performance — yet they aren’t easily quantifiable in any visible statistics for which you can screen,” he said.

Occasionally, the market does offer up multiyear compounders at deeply discounted values — he cited Apple

and Blackstone Group

as examples. But he said the firm has had just as much success buying stocks considered expensive, as long as they grew their earnings at high rates for a long period of times. In a footnote, he also noted companies including Costco
Home Depot

and Chipotle

that the firm owned but sold too early when it thought they got pricey.

The buzz

The U.S. added 532,000 nonfarm jobs in October, the Labor Department reported Friday, as the unemployment rate fell to 4.6% from 4.8%. There also was an upward revision to September’s numbers, which now show a less-disappointing 312,000 gain.


shares surged 12%, after the pharma giant said a study found its oral antiviral reduced coronavirus hospitalizations and deaths by 89%. Merck & Co.
which just saw its oral antiviral approved in the U.K., tumbled 9% as a study of its product reduces hospitalizations and deaths by 50%. Emergent Biosciences

tumbled, after the federal government canceled a contract, following the production of millions of contaminated Johnson & Johnson

vaccine doses.

The White House is asking Democratic senators to meet with Fed Chair Jerome Powell, leading some to believe President Joe Biden will renominate him, according to Axios. Sen. Sherrod Brown said the White House may roll out four nominations to the Fed, including for the vice chair for bank supervision role.

Peloton Interactive

skidded 32% after the exercise-bike maker forecast far-weaker holiday sales than analysts expected. Inventories rose 35% sequentially to $1.27 billion. RiverPark’s Rubin said Peloton was the top short in its long/short fund. He said the fund “may cover some” but there’s downside below $50 per share.


and Expedia

each benefited from an increase in travel, their latest results showed.

One RiverPark investment that’s had a rocky week is Zillow
“We are thrilled they are exiting the home buying business, and given the correction are buying more,” Rubin said in an email.


was in the unusual position of denying a press release on its own website, saying news that it will accept Bitcoin Cash

is fraudulent.

Listen to the Best New Ideas In Money podcast

The markets

After a particularly strong day for tech stocks, and the 15th gain in 17 tries for the S&P 500
U.S. stock futures



The yield on the 10-year Treasury

rose to 1.54%, and the 2-year yield

rose 4 basis points after the jobs data. The pound

was trading lower for a second day after the Bank of England’s surprise decision to keep rates unchanged.

Random reads

New York City’s mayor-elect says he will take his first three paychecks in bitcoin

— in what will be a challenge to the city’s payroll system.

Swedish pop supergroup ABBA has released its first album after 40 years.

Need to Know starts early and is updated until the opening bell, but sign up here to get it delivered once to your email box. The emailed version will be sent out at about 7:30 a.m. Eastern.

Want more for the day ahead? Sign up for The Barron’s Daily, a morning briefing for investors, including exclusive commentary from Barron’s and MarketWatch writers.

Post a Comment